Key takeaways
- An extract ratio compares starting material with finished extract.
- In tinctures, 1:3 means 1g of dried mushroom per 3ml of tincture.
- In powders, 10:1 means 10kg of mushroom made 1kg of extract; the conventions run in opposite directions.
- A ratio says nothing about compound content, starting material quality or effect.
- Compare ratios only between similar products, alongside part used and method.
1:1, 1:3, 10:1, 20:1… Extract ratios appear on many mushroom products, and they are easy to misread. The same format of numbers can mean quite different things depending on the type of product. This article explains how to read them, how to do the arithmetic, and what they can and can’t tell you.
Ratios in tinctures
For liquid extracts, ratios follow a long-standing herbal convention. A ratio such as 1:3 means one part of dried starting material to three parts of liquid; for example, 1 gram of dried mushroom for every 3 millilitres of finished tincture.
- 1:1: equal parts; a very concentrated liquid.
- 1:3 or 1:5: common for tinctures.
- 1:10: more dilute.
The smaller the second number, the more starting material per millilitre.
Ratios in extract powders
Powders are usually written the other way round. 10:1 means ten kilograms of mushroom were used to make one kilogram of extract powder. Here, the bigger the first number, the more concentrated the extract.
Why powders often land around 10:1
Hot water extraction dissolves only a minority of a mushroom’s dry weight: much of it is tough, insoluble cell-wall material such as chitin, which is filtered out. So when an extract is dried back to a powder, a large amount of mushroom naturally yields a much smaller amount of powder. Ratios well above this usually involve further concentration or purification, which can change what the extract contains.
Working out the mushroom per serving
A ratio becomes most useful when you turn it into the amount of starting material per serving.
Tinctures. Divide the serving size in millilitres by the second number of the ratio. A 1:4 tincture taken at 2ml a day represents 2 ÷ 4 = 0.5 g of dried mushroom a day.
Powders. Multiply the serving in grams by the first number. A 10:1 powder taken at 1 g a day represents 1 × 10 = 10 g of dried mushroom a day.
These are “equivalents”: they describe how much mushroom was used, not how much of any compound you are getting. See Tincture Strength: What Does ‘Strong’ Actually Mean?
Ratios in dual extracts
Dual extracts are harder to summarise with one number, because two separate extractions are combined. A simple example: if 100 g of dried mushroom is extracted in hot water to give 200 ml of liquid, and separately in alcohol to give another 200 ml, the combined 400 ml tincture could be described as 1:4 overall. Some producers quote an overall ratio like this; others describe each stage. Either is fine, as long as it is explained clearly.
What a ratio doesn’t tell you
- How much of any compound is present. Two extracts with the same ratio can differ widely depending on the starting material and method.
- Whether the starting material was good. A high ratio of grain-grown mycelium is still largely grain.
- Whether the material was fresh or dry. Fresh mushrooms are around 90% water, so a ratio based on fresh weight represents roughly a tenth as much dried mushroom as the same ratio based on dry weight.
- Whether carriers were added. An extract powder mixed with a carrier such as maltodextrin after extraction is diluted, whatever the ratio says.
- Anything about effect. A more concentrated extract isn’t a promise of a stronger or better result.
Very high powder ratios, such as 20:1 or more, can be achieved by concentrating or purifying an extract, but they don’t necessarily mean more of the compounds you might be interested in.
How to use ratios sensibly
- Compare ratios only between products of the same type.
- Check whether the ratio is based on dried or fresh material.
- Read the ratio alongside the part used and the extraction method.
- Convert it into mushroom equivalent per daily serving.
- Treat test results, not ratios, as the way to understand content.
- Be sceptical of ratios used as marketing headlines.
Our ratios
The extract ratio of each Spore & Bloom tincture is shown on its label. Each is a dual extract of UK-grown fruiting bodies, or wild Finnish chaga, made in small batches in Dorset.