Key takeaways
- “Strong” usually means concentrated, but isn’t a defined term.
- Extract strength and alcohol strength are different things.
- Concentration doesn’t guarantee compound content or effect.
- Compare the amount per daily serving, not just the label.
“Strong”, “potent” and “extra strength” appear on many tinctures and extracts. “Strength” is one of the most used, and least defined, words in mushroom marketing. This article explains what it can and can’t mean, and how to compare products fairly.
What “strong” can mean
- Extract ratio. More starting material per millilitre, such as 1:2 rather than 1:5. See Understanding Mushroom Extract Ratios.
- Compound content. How much of a measured compound, such as beta-glucans, is present, if the product has been tested.
- Alcohol strength. Sometimes confused with extract strength, but a different thing entirely. A higher alcohol percentage doesn’t mean more mushroom.
- Nothing specific. Sometimes it’s just a word on the label.
A quick guide to ratios
Tincture ratios are usually written as weight of dried mushroom to volume of liquid. A 1:2 tincture was made with 1 g of mushroom for every 2 ml of liquid; a 1:5 tincture with 1 g for every 5 ml. So 1:2 is more concentrated than 1:5. Confusingly, powder extract ratios usually run the other way, such as 10:1, meaning 10 kg of mushroom was used to make 1 kg of powder. See Understanding Mushroom Extract Ratios.
Ratio isn’t content
A more concentrated extract isn’t necessarily richer in the compounds you’re interested in. That depends on the starting material, how well it was extracted and with which solvents. A ratio tells you how much went in, not how much came out. Only testing shows content. See Beta-Glucan Testing Explained.
Starting material matters
A highly concentrated extract of grain-grown mycelium can still be largely grain. A modest extract of good fruiting bodies may contain more of what you want. See Mycelium on Grain Explained.
What “strong” can’t mean
- That the starting material was good.
- That it contains more of any particular compound, unless tested.
- That it will have a stronger effect. Be wary of products that imply otherwise.
Serving size matters
A more concentrated tincture taken in a smaller serving may deliver a similar amount of mushroom as a weaker one taken in a larger serving.
Worked example. Take two tinctures:
- Tincture A is 1:2, with a serving of 1ml. That is equivalent to 0.5 g of dried mushroom per serving.
- Tincture B is 1:5, with a serving of 3ml. That is equivalent to 0.6 g of dried mushroom per serving.
Despite being “weaker”, Tincture B delivers slightly more mushroom per serving. So compare the amount of starting material per daily serving, not just the ratio, and remember the per-bottle cost too.
How to compare fairly
- Compare ratios only between similar products, such as tincture with tincture.
- Check the part used and the extraction method.
- Look for tested figures, with the testing method stated.
- Work out the amount of starting material per daily serving.
- Compare the cost per daily serving, not per bottle.
See How to Choose a Mushroom Extract.
Each Spore & Bloom tincture shows its extract ratio on the label.