Key takeaways
- An extract has been processed with a solvent; a powder may just be dried mushroom.
- Tinctures are liquid extracts; extract powders are dried extracts.
- “Concentrate” isn’t a standard term, so check the definition.
- Check the label for method, ratio, carriers and part used.
Mushroom extracts come in several forms, and the names are used loosely. This guide sorts out the main types, how each is made, and how to tell them apart, so you know what you’re looking at.
What makes something an extract?
An extract has been processed with a solvent, usually hot water, alcohol or both, to draw compounds out of the tough fungal cell wall. The spent solids, much of them indigestible chitin, are then separated and discarded. Simply drying and grinding a mushroom produces a powder, not an extract. See The Complete Guide to Mushroom Extraction and Why Mushroom Cell Walls Matter.
The main types at a glance
| Type | What it is | Extracted? |
|---|---|---|
| Tincture | Liquid extract in water and alcohol | Yes |
| Extract powder | Extract dried to a powder | Yes |
| Concentrate | Extract with some solvent removed | Yes |
| Glycerite | Liquid extract in glycerine, alcohol-free | Yes |
| Whole mushroom powder | Dried, ground mushroom | No |
| Mycelium powder | Fungal threads, often with grain | Usually no |
| Capsules | Any of the powders, in a capsule | Depends on contents |
Tinctures
Liquid extracts in water and alcohol, taken with a dropper. Most quality mushroom tinctures are dual extracts, combining a hot water extract with an alcohol extract. The alcohol also preserves them. See What Is a Mushroom Tincture? and What Does Dual Extract Mean?
Extract powders
Extracts that have been dried, usually by spray drying, in which the liquid is sprayed as a fine mist into hot air and dries almost instantly into a powder. Some are dried onto a carrier such as maltodextrin, which should be listed in the ingredients. Most extract powders are hot water extracts only, unless an alcohol stage is stated. They are used loose or in capsules. See Raw Mushroom Powder vs Extract Powder.
Concentrates
“Concentrate” usually means an extract with some of its solvent removed, making it stronger per gram or millilitre. The term isn’t standardised, so check how a brand defines it.
Glycerites
Liquid extracts made with glycerine instead of alcohol. They are alcohol-free and sweet-tasting, but glycerine extracts fewer of the alcohol-soluble compounds, such as triterpenes, and doesn’t preserve as well.
Whole mushroom powders
Dried, ground mushroom, unextracted. Not an extract, though sometimes marketed alongside them. For culinary mushrooms, it is closer to eating the mushroom as food.
Mycelium powders
Fungal threads, often grown on grain and ground up with it. Usually unextracted. See Mycelium on Grain Explained.
How to tell them apart
- Does the label say “extract”, and name the method: hot water, alcohol or both?
- Is there an extract ratio?
- Are carriers or other ingredients listed?
- Is it fruiting body or mycelium, and is grain included?
- Does a powder dissolve in water? Extract powders often dissolve well; whole mushroom powders don’t.
For a comparison of formats, see Mushroom Tincture vs Capsules vs Powder.