Key takeaways
- Hericenones are associated with the Lion’s Mane fruiting body; erinacines mainly with the mycelium.
- Fruiting body and mycelium Lion’s Mane products aren’t interchangeable.
- Grain-grown mycelium products may contain substantial starch.
- Clear labelling of the part used matters more than either choice.
For most mushrooms, the difference between fruiting body and mycelium products is mainly about grain and transparency. For Lion’s Mane, there is an extra twist: its two best-known groups of compounds are found in different parts of the fungus. This article explains what that means, what the research used, and how to choose.
Two parts, two chemistries
- Hericenones are associated with the Lion’s Mane fruiting body. They were discovered in Japan in the early 1990s. See Hericenones Explained.
- Erinacines are found mainly in the mycelium, and are present in the fruiting body in very small amounts, if at all. They were discovered a few years later, by the same research group. See Erinacines Explained.
Both groups have attracted research interest, largely in laboratory and animal studies. Both parts also contain beta-glucans, sterols and other compounds.
Which part did the research use?
This is one of the most important questions when reading Lion’s Mane claims. The small number of human trials used different materials:
- Several Japanese trials used dried fruiting body powder.
- A Taiwanese trial used mycelium specially enriched with erinacine A, grown in the laboratory.
- A UK trial used a branded fruiting body extract.
So claims based on erinacine research don’t apply to fruiting body products, and claims based on fruiting body research don’t apply to mycelium products. See Lion’s Mane Research.
The grain question
Many Lion’s Mane mycelium products are grown on grain and sold with the grain included, so the finished powder can contain a lot of starch. Even if erinacines are present, it’s hard to know how much, or how much of the product is actually fungus. Few such products state an erinacine content, and fewer still show testing for it. See Mycelium on Grain Explained.
How the two compare
| Fruiting body | Mycelium on grain | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | The mushroom itself | Fungal threads grown through grain |
| Hericenones | Associated with this part | Not characteristic |
| Erinacines | Very little, if any | May be present; rarely measured |
| Grain starch | None | Often substantial |
| Eaten as food | Yes, for centuries | No |
| Cost to produce | Higher | Lower |
So which should you choose?
That depends on what you’re looking for, and on honest labelling:
- A fruiting body product gives you the mushroom itself, the same part eaten as food in East Asia.
- A mycelium product should tell you how it was grown, whether grain is included and, ideally, what testing shows, including any erinacine content, with the method.
- Some brands combine both; if so, they should say in what proportion.
What matters most is that the label tells you clearly which you’re buying.
Our choice
Our Lion’s Mane tincture is made only from UK-grown Lion’s Mane fruiting bodies. We don’t use mycelium, and we don’t claim it contains erinacines. For the general picture, see Fruiting Body vs Mycelium; for the species, The Complete Guide to Lion’s Mane.