In Vitro, Animal and Human Studies: What's the Difference?

A result in cells, in mice and in people are not the same thing. This article explains in vitro, animal and human studies, and systematic reviews, and what each can and can’t tell us.

In Vitro, Animal and Human Studies: What's the Difference?

Key takeaways

  • In vitro studies test cells in the lab; animal studies test living animals.
  • Only human studies can show what happens in people.
  • Randomised controlled trials are the most reliable single studies.
  • Systematic reviews combine studies but depend on their quality.

“Studies show…” can mean very different things. A result in a dish of cells, a result in mice and a result in people are not equivalent. This article explains the main types of study, how they fit together into a hierarchy of evidence, and what each can and can’t tell us.

In vitro studies

In vitro means “in glass”. These studies test compounds or extracts on cells or tissues in the laboratory, in dishes or test tubes.

Strengths: quick, cheap, well controlled, and good for exploring how something might work at the level of a cell.

Limitations: cells in a dish behave very differently from a whole body. The compound is applied directly to the cells, skipping digestion, absorption, the liver and everything else a swallowed substance meets. Concentrations used are often far higher than anything reached by eating or taking a supplement. And cells grown in labs, often from a single cell line, may not behave like the cells in your body.

Animal studies

Animal studies, usually in mice or rats, test effects in a living organism with digestion, metabolism and circulation.

Strengths: closer to real life than cells, and they allow researchers to study things that couldn’t be done in people.

Limitations: animals differ from people in their biology, lifespan and metabolism. Doses are often far higher than human use when scaled by body weight, and the preparations used may bear little resemblance to commercial products. Animals are sometimes given a condition artificially, such as a high-cholesterol diet, which may not reflect how that condition develops in people. Many results in animals are never reproduced in people.

Human studies

Human studies come in several kinds, of very different strength:

  • Case reports describe individual patients. They can raise alarms, such as the reports of kidney problems linked to chaga, but can’t prove cause and effect or show how common something is. See Chaga Research.
  • Observational studies look at patterns in populations, such as the Swedish study linking blood ergothioneine levels with long-term outcomes. They can be large and long, but can’t prove cause and effect. See Ergothioneine Explained. Studies of mushroom eating and memory in older adults are another example; see Mushrooms in the Diet and Cognition.
  • Pilot studies are small, sometimes without a control group, and help plan larger trials.
  • Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) compare a treatment with a placebo or control, with participants randomly assigned. When they are also double-blinded, so neither participants nor researchers know who received what, they are the most reliable single studies.

Systematic reviews

Systematic reviews gather all the available studies on a question using a pre-planned, transparent method, and assess their quality. Meta-analyses go further, combining the numbers statistically. Cochrane reviews are widely regarded as among the most rigorous. They sit near the top of the evidence hierarchy, although their conclusions depend on the quality of the studies they include: pooling several poor studies doesn’t make good evidence. See Reishi Research for an example.

The hierarchy of evidence

Researchers often picture the types of evidence as a pyramid, from weakest at the bottom to strongest at the top, for questions about whether something works in people:

  1. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses of good trials
  2. Randomised controlled trials
  3. Observational studies
  4. Case reports
  5. Animal and laboratory studies, and expert opinion

The pyramid is a guide, not a rule: a large, well-run observational study can be more informative than a tiny, flawed trial. And laboratory and animal studies are essential for understanding mechanisms and safety, even if they can’t show what happens in people.

Why the distinction matters

When you read about mushroom research, the first question to ask is always: what kind of study was it? See How to Read Mushroom Research and How to Judge the Quality of a Mushroom Study.

Last reviewed . How we research and write

Join the Spore & Bloom Journal

Receive occasional notes on mushrooms, botanical extraction, new releases and events.

We write occasionally and never share your address. Unsubscribe at any time.